Propane Refill & Exchange in Indianapolis, IN
12 propane refill and exchange options in Indianapolis, IN — hardware store, propane supplier, gas station and truck rental agency — each with a published phone number so you can call and confirm price, hours and tank size before you go.
Listings below are shown for information only, using publicly available contact details. Portable Propane Heater has no business relationship with the businesses listed, does not vet or endorse them, and is not paid for any listing. Confirm details directly with a business before relying on this information.
Affiliate Disclosure
Some links on this page are affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases — at no extra cost to you. Commissions never change our verdicts. How we rank & full disclosure.
Refilling vs. Exchanging in Indianapolis
Exchange — common at hardware stores, gas stations and home-improvement retailers — swaps your empty cylinder for a filled one on the spot, though exchange cylinders are typically filled to around 15 lb rather than a 20 lb tank's full capacity. Refilling at a dedicated propane dealer fills the same tank to its actual rated capacity and is usually cheaper per gallon, but takes a few minutes longer and isn't offered at every location below. Call ahead to check which service a listing offers — see our full refill vs. exchange breakdown for the cost comparison.
12 Propane Refill & Exchange Providers in Indianapolis, IN
From public Google Maps business data for "propane refill" and "propane tank exchange" — contact any of them directly; we don't take your details or route your call.
- 1
Fusek's True Value
609 N Delaware St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Public listing only — not an endorsement, referral, or paid placement. Confirm details directly with the business.
- 2
Sutton-Garten Co.
901 N Senate Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46202
Public listing only — not an endorsement, referral, or paid placement. Confirm details directly with the business.
- 3
Marathon Gas
2160 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46225
Public listing only — not an endorsement, referral, or paid placement. Confirm details directly with the business.
- 4
Propane Refill at U-Haul
4011 S East St, Indianapolis, IN 46227
Public listing only — not an endorsement, referral, or paid placement. Confirm details directly with the business.
- 5
Speedway
401 Kentucky Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46225
Public listing only — not an endorsement, referral, or paid placement. Confirm details directly with the business.
- 6
Propane Refill at U-Haul
2960 Lafayette Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46222
Public listing only — not an endorsement, referral, or paid placement. Confirm details directly with the business.
- 7
ARCO
3510 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46217
Public listing only — not an endorsement, referral, or paid placement. Confirm details directly with the business.
- 8
2 Good To Go
324 W Morris St, Indianapolis, IN 46225
Public listing only — not an endorsement, referral, or paid placement. Confirm details directly with the business.
- 9
Propane Refill & Exchange at U-Haul
7425 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46219
Public listing only — not an endorsement, referral, or paid placement. Confirm details directly with the business.
- 10
Propane Refill & Exchange at U-Haul
5245 W Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46241
Public listing only — not an endorsement, referral, or paid placement. Confirm details directly with the business.
- 11
U-Haul Moving & Storage of Downtown Indianapolis
1430 N Illinois St, Indianapolis, IN 46202
Public listing only — not an endorsement, referral, or paid placement. Confirm details directly with the business.
- 12
Garfield Park Market
2359 Shelby St, Indianapolis, IN 46203
Public listing only — not an endorsement, referral, or paid placement. Confirm details directly with the business.
Listing data from public Google Maps business listings, as of September 4, 2026. Google ratings shown are each business's publicly displayed rating on that date and may have changed. Request a correction or removal.
Propane Tank & Accessory Picks
Handy if you're thinking about buying your own tank instead of always exchanging — real products, tap through for the live price.
Best for connecting an older POL-valve tank to newer QCC1 hoses and regulators
Best for switching tanks automatically on an RV or dual-tank setup
Best for connecting a larger 100 lb tank at extra distance